Marc-Andre ter Stegen 7 - Good save from Parejo and another from Rodrigo, decisive interventions.
Nelson Semedo 7 - Unjustly subbed off when he was the best player in the first half, earned the penalty for Messi.
Gerard Pique 4 - Valencia’s speed in attack hurt him, not a consistent performance.
Tommy Vermaelen 4 - All the biggest Valencia chances came from his side, they beat him far too easily.
Sergi Roberto 5 - Gave away the penalty playing at left-back, better after moving to the right.
Ivan Rakitic 5 - Could not influence on a defensive level despite playing pivote, in attack lacked fluidity.
Carlos Alena 7 - Showed a lot of personality and took responsibility, asking for the ball, combining well.
Arturo Vidal 5 - His work-rate saves him but a Barca midfielder should offer a lot more.
Leo Messi 7 - Took the penalty and curled home an excellent second. After taking a knock he kept playing.
Philippe Coutinho 5 - Showed some signs of quality but is not at his level and cannot get into the game.
Luis Suarez 5 - No chances, worked hard but could not break through.